I have all three of them, picked them up all up at the same time as they were a good deal. I only wanted to try the original and mentholated, but they were so cheap I thought why not. I only use them as an aftershave, and they work great I like all of them. Plus points for me are they are great for warm weather and if you want something without a lingering scent, the scents are mild and do not last too long. You can't go wrong for the price.