I have never tried a Witch Hazel lotion before, so today I bought the Boots and Thornton and Ross Care version from Superdrug. As well as trying it as a stand alone lotion, I am considering making my own aftershave. I am guessing that the following ingredients are required: Alcohol: I have Spirytus 95 Witch Hazel Glycerin: I have food grade Essential Oils: I will probably go with Grapefruit and Lime Do I need distilled water or castor oil? I know that Bay Rums have been attempted? Anyone tried making an AS?