Closed Pass Around: Supply Provision Single Edge - CLOSED

Shave #6 Singe Edge vs. Bunny V3

The Single Edge on the left hand side of my face, the might Bunny V3 on the right hand side. I'm using the Bunny with the 'Mild' plate - my standard setting and the Single Edge with the 'Classic' plate. I started the shave with the Single Edge and then switched to the Bunny. Something was wrong on the Bunny side and I remembered that the Schick blade in the Bunny had been used for quite some time. I checked later and it would have been shave number 10 with the same blade. I quickly injected a new Schick blade and all was well.
The two half-shaves were similar in blade feel, but very different in razor feel. The Single Edge needs the normal injector angle, the Bunny needs its own very quirky angle. I have no real preference. However, the Single Edge is too heavy. Injectors are nimble - the Single Edge isn't. The Bunny is so much more fun when moving it around my face. Razor weight is a very personal thing, but I believe the Single Edge would be a better razor if it was made from aluminium.
In the end I had a pleasurable shave all over, helped by the excellent De Vergulde Hand soap. Good stuff. As I expected, the Bunny gave me a slightly closer shave and the shave lasted longer. The difference is not massive, but it's there.
I'll have at least one more Bunny vs Single Edge shave.
To be continued...
Interesting observations. I don't like heavy razors -- I decided to sell the SR71 slant in about five minutes-- but I find the Single Edge quite manageable. Perhaps it's the balance, but even on my head shave where I light touch I find the SE just on the good side of heavy.

Sent from my Nexus 5X using Tapatalk
 
Interesting observations. I don't like heavy razors -- I decided to sell the SR71 slant in about five minutes-- but I find the Single Edge quite manageable. Perhaps it's the balance, but even on my head shave where I light touch I find the SE just on the good side of heavy.
I swear my preference for light or heavy razors changes with the phase of the moon. Some days the Merkur 45 at 15g is perfect and I had no issues with the Hone Type 15 at more than eleven times that. But the Single Edge feels wrong. For me. I have this thing in my brain telling me what an injector should feel like... Maybe I need a few more shaves with it.
Don't get me wrong - it's not hideously heavy... it just doesn't feel right.. somehow... when there is a waxing gibbous
moon with 88% illumination - like today.
 
Shave #7 Singe Edge vs. Bunny V3 - Round 2
I switched sides today. The Single Edge on the right hand side of my face, the Bunny V3 on the left hand side. I also used the 'NOTSO' plate on the Bunny.
I was hoping to learn something new today, but I haven't. The Bunny still gives the better shave, but the difference was a little bit less than yesterday.
I'll have another shave with a Personna blade tomorrow and then I'll have run out of things to try with the Single Edge and it will be time for my final verdict and for the next person on the list (@p.b) to have a go.
To be continued...
 
Afternoon Andreas, is it possible for me to please be added to the lis?

Ta, Richard
Afternoon, Richard.
Certainly.
  1. sɐǝɹpu∀ / riverrun (ATG/TSR)
  2. p.b (ATG)
  3. Mr Bigmem (ATG/TSR)
  4. Rowlers (ATG)
  5. Glenn_Lee (TSR)
  6. You?
The list is open.
Legend: Currently with, On the way to, Waiting, Completed
 
Just one observation today:
I injected a Personna blade into the Single Edge for today's shave.
I had slight problems injecting Schick blades a few days ago. This seems to be a common problem with the Single Edge V1.
However, the Personna blade went from the crappy white plastic magazine into the head very smoothly. So I injected another one. And another one. And another one. Smooth as butter every single time. Go figure. This is finally an injector razor that plays nicely with the plastic Personna magazines.
After putting all those Personna blades back in the magazine I decided that I didn't feel like having a shave today after all.
Postponed until tomorrow....
 
Some thoughts on weight
Warning: If you are easily offended by crappy image maipulation, please skip this article.

The Single Edge weighs 108g. I think it's a bit much, others like it that way.
It would be even heavier if it didn't have a recessed section on the underside of the razor:
Bottom.jpg

Personally, I find this recess detracts from the elegance and good looks of the razor.
I calculated that the Single Edge made from aluminium would weigh 37g (and probably be cheaper), made from titanium it would weigh a sweet 63g (and probably cost a fortune).
Having thus reduced the weight, the recess would no longer be necessary and by adding back a little weight the underside could look nearly as elegant as the top of the razor.
If you promise not to be offended by crappy image manipulation (I have warned you twice now!) have a look at this for a rough idea what I mean:
Bottom.gif

I'm afraid the looks of the razor have been sacrificed in favour of the adoration of the stainless steel calf.
 
They also curiously switched the dot location to the hidden side. Drives me nuts.
Absolutely. I mentioned this earlier in this thread:
You can't tell which plate is installed by looking at the razor. The dots are on the inside of the head. You have to disassemble the razor or look at the two other plates. Bad user interface design.
 
The razor has been sent to @p.b this morning.
My final thoughts will follow shortly.

  1. sɐǝɹpu∀ / riverrun (ATG/TSR)
  2. p.b (ATG)
  3. Mr Bigmem (ATG/TSR)
  4. Rowlers (ATG)
  5. Glenn_Lee (TSR)
  6. You?
The list is open.
Legend: Currently with, On the way to, Waiting, Completed
 
A little delayed, but here is...
Supply Provision Single Edge V1 - My final verdict

Let's start with the looks of the razor: overall it's quite a handsome beast. I like the lines and the finish is quite good. I still think the top looks better than the bottom, but I could say the same about most injectors. However, I believe the razor would look better without the recessed bit on the bottom side. See one of my previous posts.
The size of the razor is very good. It's a bit shorter than my J and N type Schicks and a bit longer than the Bunny V3, but overall it's the shape of a proper injector razor. The Single Edge takes normal injector blades and not Feather AC style blades, which makes the head a decent width. In my opinion all heads for Feather AC blades are too wide.
Although I got used to the weight of the razor, I still feel it's too heavy for an injector. That's my own very personal opinion and other may like the heft. The choice of stainless steel is a bad one for this razor. It makes it too heavy and it also causes it looks to be compromised. May I suggest titanium, aluminium or (dare I say it? - I dare!) zinc alloy as better materials for this razor?
Let's look at the three plates supplied with the razor. The thing I like about them is that they actually make a difference. The plates on the Bunny V3 are all very similar, which is not a problem as they are all perfect for me. The 'Classic' plate is the one for me. It gives comfortable yet close shaves. The 'Mild' plate on the Single edge is Mild, too mild for my taste and the 'Aggressive' plate is markedly more direct while not improving the closeness of the shave. Personally I'd be happy with the 'Classic' plate only, but I can see that some guys might want a choice and the Single Edge gives you that. Who's idea was it to put the dots indicating which plate you are using on the inside of the head? Really? WTF? Whoever came up with this - read ↪this book..
Changing plates is easier with the Bunny V3, but it's no a big issue. The screw is on the big side and partly obscured by the head. The design of the head is interesting though. It's the only injector I know where you can change blades without using a blade magazine. A real bonus if you want to use cut to size Feather AC blades.
Changing blades was a bit of an issue. Using a Chinese Schick magazine I had slight problems with the new blade not always ejecting the old one and being inserted above the blade already in the head. This is not good and seems to be a well known problem of this razor. Allegedly this has been fixed in the latest version of the razor. Amazingly I had no problems with Personna blades and their crappy plastic magazines.
The choice of blades is good, but for some reason twin blades won't work. Pity. My recommendation for this razor are definitely Personna blades. No problems injecting them and they were just as good as the Schicks for me in this razor. This is a big plus!
The most important aspect of a razor is of course how well it shaves. And the Single Edge doesn't disappoint. It gives easy and close shaves. For some reason it did struggle a bit with my difficult area just underneath the jawline. I always struggle there, but injectors normally work better for me, except this one. So while the shaves were not up there with the best, the results were certainly better than average. If this was the first injector razor I ever tried, I'd be mightily impressed. Unfortunately (for the Single Edge, fortunately for me) I have a Bunny V3 at my disposal and the Single Edge can't compete. Overall this is a very competent shaver and if you're after a modern injector razor I'd recommend it without hesitation.
Would I buy one? No. It's too heavy for my taste and the design of the underside of the razor would annoy me every time I'd use it. It would see little action as I'd prefer to use the Bunny V3 or my vintage Schick N3.
It's an interesting razor though and some will like the idea of a stainless steel injector and if you do, you can give this razor a go and join the pass around.
Thanks to @Blademonkey for making this pass around possible.
 
The razor is now with @p.b
  1. sɐǝɹpu∀ / riverrun (ATG/TSR)
  2. p.b (ATG)
  3. Mr Bigmem (ATG/TSR)
  4. Rowlers (ATG)
  5. Glenn_Lee (TSR)
  6. matteob (TSR)
  7. You?
The list is open.
Legend: Currently with, On the way to, Waiting, Completed
 
A little delayed, but here is...
Supply Provision Single Edge V1 - My final verdict

Let's start with the looks of the razor: overall it's quite a handsome beast. I like the lines and the finish is quite good. I still think the top looks better than the bottom, but I could say the same about most injectors. However, I believe the razor would look better without the recessed bit on the bottom side. See one of my previous posts.
The size of the razor is very good. It's a bit shorter than my J and N type Schicks and a bit longer than the Bunny V3, but overall it's the shape of a proper injector razor. The Single Edge takes normal injector blades and not Feather AC style blades, which makes the head a decent width. In my opinion all heads for Feather AC blades are too wide.
Although I got used to the weight of the razor, I still feel it's too heavy for an injector. That's my own very personal opinion and other may like the heft. The choice of stainless steel is a bad one for this razor. It makes it too heavy and it also causes it looks to be compromised. May I suggest titanium, aluminium or (dare I say it? - I dare!) zinc alloy as better materials for this razor?
Let's look at the three plates supplied with the razor. The thing I like about them is that they actually make a difference. The plates on the Bunny V3 are all very similar, which is not a problem as they are all perfect for me. The 'Classic' plate is the one for me. It gives comfortable yet close shaves. The 'Mild' plate on the Single edge is Mild, too mild for my taste and the 'Aggressive' plate is markedly more direct while not improving the closeness of the shave. Personally I'd be happy with the 'Classic' plate only, but I can see that some guys might want a choice and the Single Edge gives you that. Who's idea was it to put the dots indicating which plate you are using on the inside of the head? Really? WTF? Whoever came up with this - read ↪this book..
Changing plates is easier with the Bunny V3, but it's no a big issue. The screw is on the big side and partly obscured by the head. The design of the head is interesting though. It's the only injector I know where you can change blades without using a blade magazine. A real bonus if you want to use cut to size Feather AC blades.
Changing blades was a bit of an issue. Using a Chinese Schick magazine I had slight problems with the new blade not always ejecting the old one and being inserted above the blade already in the head. This is not good and seems to be a well known problem of this razor. Allegedly this has been fixed in the latest version of the razor. Amazingly I had no problems with Personna blades and their crappy plastic magazines.
The choice of blades is good, but for some reason twin blades won't work. Pity. My recommendation for this razor are definitely Personna blades. No problems injecting them and they were just as good as the Schicks for me in this razor. This is a big plus!
The most important aspect of a razor is of course how well it shaves. And the Single Edge doesn't disappoint. It gives easy and close shaves. For some reason it did struggle a bit with my difficult area just underneath the jawline. I always struggle there, but injectors normally work better for me, except this one. So while the shaves were not up there with the best, the results were certainly better than average. If this was the first injector razor I ever tried, I'd be mightily impressed. Unfortunately (for the Single Edge, fortunately for me) I have a Bunny V3 at my disposal and the Single Edge can't compete. Overall this is a very competent shaver and if you're after a modern injector razor I'd recommend it without hesitation.
Would I buy one? No. It's too heavy for my taste and the design of the underside of the razor would annoy me every time I'd use it. It would see little action as I'd prefer to use the Bunny V3 or my vintage Schick N3.
It's an interesting razor though and some will like the idea of a stainless steel injector and if you do, you can give this razor a go and join the pass around.
Thanks to @Blademonkey for making this pass around possible.
You are welcome @riverrun and thank you for your comprehensive and honest report.
 
Back
Top Bottom