Welcome Nick! This wet shaving game is very much like car detailing; you know you don't need another soap but you just have to scratch that itch on your quest for "the one". You'll fit right in here.
I don't get to spend much time caressing the car nowadays since the kids came along, but when I do I turn to Sonax stuff. Their LSP's seem to have excellent staying power and go on in a jiffy - more time for shaving lol.