Both available in Colonia. I prefer the lotion over the balm purely because I rarely use a balm in warmer weather.
There's a lot in the Colonia line which all add up to boosting the projection and longevity of Colonia, I'm a bit of a ‘full kit wanker' with Colonia.
Shampoo and conditioner, shower gel, talc, deodorant, bar soap, body lotion, balm, as lotion, edc.
Unreasonable to think everyone can buy the above so I'd look for deals on bar soap, body lotion, as lotion and edc.
All the above can usually be found being sold very cheap on eBay as travel sizes as a try before you buy.