Consensus on performance, obviously differing views on scent.
For mine, the scent is fresh, bright, lifting, and reminiscent of a dawn walk through a rain forest. As it happens, I've never done a dawn walk through a rain forest, so that part is complete bollocks, but you get the drift.
There's been some debate about the "new" formula. From what I can see, there's almost no difference. The only change seems to be from an aloe gel to a powder, and some say the powder allows for greater concentration of aloe to be loaded into the cream, hence this is why in the new formula, aloe is down the list of ingredients (less needed to get the same effect).