One soap to rule them all?

[Hedomystico]

All things considered (lather quality, availability, price...) I would say Proraso wins hands down. Green tub for the warmer months and red tub for winter.
However, MWF and Intitut Karite also rank very highly in my books due to their superior post-shave properties.

 

[Leslie145]

If I had to choose, it would definitely be Proraso green or Erasmic (black bowl) for me. Both great performers & cheap too

 

[Tardisbasher]

MdC Original. The only soap I've ever finished....and not just because of the price.

 

[BigBoar]

Now Cella. Cheap and outperforms proraso