OK the soap sample arrived this morning so I melted it in to a tub and I've just managed to have a shave and see what it's like.
Well for a first attempt I'd say it is pretty good. The scent is strong but I think I've decided that Bay Rum is not really the scent for me. This is nothing against Steve's soap as it smells similar to other bay rums I've used in the past so I reckon you've nailed the scent. The lather I managed to produce was good, though not quite up to Palmolive standards which I use as a benchmark, but definitely as good as some other commercial soaps. Now for the only downer which, from the irritation I got, is presumably the cushioning. I didn't find the actual shave that easy and when I'd finished I had to use some balm, which I don't usually have to do. I will have another shave with it tomorrow using a different razor and blade to make sure the problem wasn't other factors.
For someone with no experience of soapmaking I'd say this was a damn good effort and I am sure you'll go far!
I wonder how the others got on testing your soap?